Wirtz Premier League Slump Creates Dilemma: Two Generations of Reds Legends Divide on Approach, Winter Window May Bring Make-or-Break Decision

Former Reds player Danny Pennant told GOAL that Wirtz has scored just 7 goals in his first Premier League season, falling far short of his Bundesliga peak form of 20+ goal contributions per season, and has yet to find his footing in the 2026-27 campaign. Pennant believes the new manager's tactical adjustments could be a turning point, adding that Liverpool will not rush to sell such a top-class player, as the squad needs him to bolster its depth. However, Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher has taken a firm stance, pointing out that Wirtz drifts around the pitch with insufficient defensive commitment, drawing frustration from teammates. Carragher insists Wirtz must earn his place through offensive output, warning that if the slump persists, the club could act in the winter transfer window.